Property Rights Foundation of America®
Founded 1994

Book Reviews

Greenism Anatomized
Book Review by Jigs Gardner

Green Hell: How environmentalists plan to comtrol your life and what you can do to stop them
By Steve Milloy. 2009. 235 pp.Regnery. $27.95

There are many books which examine Green claims, exposing their fallacies, and the author lists eighteen excellent books (as well as some films) in an appendix so that readers can judge the basis on which Milloy mounts his attack. Given the fraudulence of Green arguments, he may then devote all his attention to the consequences of their policies and goals. By thus framing his argument, Milloy is able to concentrate his narrative, making it extremely effective. That his writing is clear, concise, and straight forward is a great help. There is not an empty paragraph in the book.

Each chapter describes a different aspect of the Green assault on our lives. Chapter One, "The Rationing Rationale", opens with an account of the cheery public face of Greenism advocating "sustainable" living, propaganda which he exposes by citing a 2008 issue of New Scientist magazine with the theme: "The Folly of Growth: How to stop the economic killing of the planet," in which various professors and prominent Greens advocate de-development because they regard wealth as destructive of the environment. The rest of the chapter develops this theme, covering issues like the "carbon footprint," carbon rationing, proposals to meter (and control) individual electricity use, "smart growth"–forcing people into high density urban areas, Zero Population Growth. This is done comprehensively, so that we learn exactly what the Greens are up to and why, as well as their disguises. The next chapter, "Power is Power," shows how Greens fight the development of every source of energy, despite paying lip service to "renewable energy." As Milloy points out,

Greens don't really want to increase our energy supply . . . because that would undermine virtually all of the Green's ultimate goals: zero population growth, limiting the development of physical infrastructure, impeding economic growth, and redistributing wealth.

Chapter Three is about anti-car activism and all the measures Greens promote to make it expensive and inconvenient to drive. Milloy documents the folly of hybrid cars, shows Green opposition to new roads, and the pressure to raise fuel economy standards–which means lighter, more dangerous cars. The new standards will cost more than $35 million a day in human lives to save $1 million in gas. It is close, documented analysis like this which gives the book such a strong impact.

In other chapters, the author shows the fatuity of other Green concerns, like the fake water "crisis," meat-eating, "slow food" ("locavores"), biotechnology, and modern agriculture. Milloy's thoroughness is demonstrated in the chapter "Kiss Your Health and Safety Goodbye," when he shows Green attacks on chlorine, asbestos, chlorofluorocarbons, DDT, pesticides, incandescent light bulbs, flame retardants, forestry (by preventing logging, Greens have ensured the overgrowth of forests, filled with debris and dead trees, leading to devastating fires), vaccines, mercury (emitted by coal-fired electricity plants). In a brilliant chapter, "The New Social Order," Milloy points out that wealthy Greens will be able to avoid the Spartan lives they have helped to force on the rest of us, showing the hypocrisy of the World Wildlife Fund whose website promotes a self-denying life at the same time that it offers its donors an around-the-world trip by a luxurious private jet, seeing "top wild life" while enjoying "gourmet meals, chilled champagne, and your own chef" at a cost of nearly $65,000. Milloy calls it "luxury eco-tourism." As the author shows, this sort of behavior is common among the wealthy attracted to Greenism.

Something that will strike home to Property Rights members is Milloy's description of deals of the Nature Conservancy, buying land supposedly to preserve it and then selling ti to wealthy friends and donors, as well as performing legerdemain with properties, tax donations, and in-house sales.

The chapter on Green coercion of corporations, whose leadership is nearly always spineless, is chilling, as Milloy shows how one corporation after another has given in to Green pressure, forced to back Green policies–like refusing loans for energy development–as part of the movement for "corporate social responsibility." He thinks that Greenism has become so powerful in recent years because Greens have intimidated big business, which is "increasingly lobbying for greenhouse gas regulation."

There's a chapter on Obama, "The First Green President," which includes this telling quote from The Daily Telegraph after Obama's election:

For 300 years science helped to turn Western civilization into the richest and most comfortable the world has ever seen. Now it seems we have suddenly been plunged into a new age of superstition, where scientific evidence no longer counts for anything. The fact that America will soon be ruled by a man wholly under the spell of this post-scientific hysteria may leave us in wondering despair.

In the last chapter, "Fighting Back," the author shows how we will all be harmed by Green success, pointing out that "No matter what your particular political outlook... there are ways in which your own concerns will be pushed aside by the Green juggernaut." He goes on to analyze Green rhetoric, revealing its fallacies, encouraging readers to see through it, an important lesson because that smooth rhetoric (think of "sustainability") tends to put us on the defensive, always fatal to opposition. He advocates activism in various ways, paying special attention to corporate shareholder's meetings, devoting several informative pages to showing how this works. Finally, Milloy ends on an eminently sensible and bracing note:

While there's no "vast green conspiracy" that meets regularly to plot and plan, the disparate groups that comprise the green movement are all working toward a common goal–increasing government control of your life. Our goal is to make sure that day never comes–and we have our work cut out for us.

A wonderful book, written with great intelligence, force, and clarity, recommended to all my readers.

Back to:
Book Reviews PRFA Home Page
   

 

© 2011 Property Rights Foundation of America®
All rights reserved. This material may not be broadcast, published, rewritten or redistributed without written permission.